Florida Trend
Get FREE Business News Updates


October 9, 2015


Niagara Bottling's Fall

Lake County economic developers lured the company in, then spit it out.

Cynthia Barnett | 3/1/2008

But while Hess spent many hours with regional and local economic developers, as well as city and county staff, most local elected officials didn’t know about the plan.

When the plan finally went public, the public went ballistic. Water-supply problems in the county are more than obvious: The same epic drought that’s gripping the rest of Florida and the Southeast has reduced its beautiful namesake lakes to puddles. The idea of a bottler tapping the county’s most important resource created what longtimers say was the loudest — and broadest — public outcry in memory.

The elected officials, including a county commissioner who had met with Hess and supported Niagara’s plans, got the water religion. Two months after Hess closed on the property, Lake County commissioners unanimously voted down Niagara’s incentive package. Groveland city commissioners, meanwhile, unanimously denied the company’s request for the sanitary sewer connection that’s crucial to Niagara’s operations.

On the q.t.

Brian Hess
Supply Line: California-based Niagara Bottling — a $300-million, family-owned company — produces private-label bottled water for Costco, Albertsons and many Vegas casinos. [Photo courtesy Niagara Bottling]
Niagara Bottling Co. went “from hero to zero — overnight,” Hess says. “It is the absolute most unfair thing I’ve ever seen.”

The issue, elected officials say, is not economic development or growth vs. no growth. It’s water. Lake County is front and center in Florida’s water crisis: Water managers have told local officials they must find and fund alternative sources by 2013, when population growth will outstrip sustainable groundwater supply. The county has been warring with neighboring developments, including The Villages, over permits to pump groundwater and over possible diversions of surface water. “The idea of having a company mine our water resources and ship them out of the county when we are asking people to conserve and pay for alternative sources is just ridiculous,” says Lake County Commissioner Elaine Renick.

Tags: Politics & Law, Central, Agriculture, Environment, Government/Politics & Law

Digital Access

Add digital to your current subscription, purchase a single digital issue, or start a new subscription to Florida Trend.

An overview of the features and articles in this month's issue of Florida Trend.


Florida Business News

Florida Trend Video Pick

Size, scope and offerings of one of Florida's largest hospitals
Size, scope and offerings of one of Florida's largest hospitals

James Burkhart, president & CEO of Tampa General Hospital details the medical center's size and service area, expresses the hospital's commitment to dispersed access care and expounds on the expanding use of electronic medical records.

Earlier Videos | Viewpoints@FloridaTrend

Ballot Box

About the proposed open-carry gun law: Are you in favor of allowing Floridians with concealed-handgun permits to openly display their weapons?

  • No
  • Yes

See Results

Ballot Box