October 22, 2014

A Florida TaxWatch economic report

The Effect of Changes in the National Flood Insurance Program on Florida

| 11/20/2013

Which Florida Counties are most affected?

Florida has more than 2.05 million policies and 268,648 (13 percent) are subsidized.6 As these policies are moved to actuarially-sound rates, as required in the Reform Act, Pinellas, Miami-Dade, and Lee counties will be most affected by the subsequent increases in policy costs, as these counties contain almost 48 percent of the subsidized policies.

Although not the leader in subsidized policies, Monroe County has, by far, the highest density of subsidized policies, with 2,244 per 10,000 housing units, more than double the density of Florida’s next-highest county: Pinellas, which leads in number of subsidized policies.

Top Florida Counties with Subsidized NFIP Policies
County
# Subsidized
policies
Subsidies Per
10k Units
Pinellas
50,255 998
Miami-Dade
47,442 479
Lee
30,398 819
Broward
19,425 240
Sarasota
18,770 822
Collier
17,133 868
Hillsborough
14,368 268
Monroe 11,840 2,244

Floridians paid $3.60 in Premiums for Every $1 collected in Flood Claims

States Receiving More in Payout $ Than They Paid in Premiums
State Claim $ Paid Per Premium Dollar
Mississippi
$5.00
Louisiana
$3.33
Alabama
$2.50
Missouri
$2.50
North Dakota
$2.50
Iowa
$2.00
Texas
$1.43
Minnesota
$1.43
West Virginia
$1.43
Oklahoma
$1.11
Kentucky $1.11
1978 - 2008 NFIP Data

In a study done by the Wharton Center for Risk Management and Decision Processes, the amount of claims paid to states was compared to the amount of flood insurance premiums collected over the period of 1978–2008.7 This study showed that Floridians paid $3.60 in premiums for every $1 collected in flood claims from the program. This put Florida as the 14th-largest donor to the program. Leading the pack were Colorado ($15.1) and New Mexico ($10.4) in premiums paid per dollar received in claims during the period of the study.

Interestingly, 11 states have received more in payouts over the 30-year period of the study than their policyholders paid in premiums, with 6 of those states receiving double or higher what they paid in premiums.

6 Map: NFIP Policyholders: Total Number of Subsidized Policies by State and County (as of 12/31/2012).
7 Catastrophe Economics: The National Flood Insurance Program, Journal of Economic Perspectives. Volume 24, Number 4. Fall 2010.

 

» NEXT PAGE: The Effects on Florida Individuals, Businesses and Local Governments

Tags: Government/Politics & Law, Insurance, Florida TaxWatch

Comments

Digital Access

DIRECT DIGITAL ACCESS
Add digital to your current subscription, purchase a single ditgital issue, or start a new subscription to Florida Trend.

TABLE OF CONTENTS
An overview of the features and articles in this month's issue of Florida Trend.

ACCESS THIS ISSUE »

Florida Business News

Florida Trend Video Pick

Gasoline Prices: Why Are They Going Down Now?
Gasoline Prices: Why Are They Going Down Now?

Gasoline prices in the U.S. are the lowest they've been in four years. Why?

Earlier Videos | Viewpoints@FloridaTrend

Ballot Box

Jeb Bush has said he'd accept tax increases as long as they are paired with federal spending cuts. This stance runs counter to conservatives who oppose tax hikes. Is Bush right?

  • Yes - raising taxes should be considered
  • No - there's enough money, need to manage it better

See Results

Ballot Box
Subscribe