July 15, 2019

Florida Law

Shopping for Verdicts

Florida's Middle District is well-regarded, and juries there are known are being conservative. That makes the district attractive for high-profile cases.

Art Levy | 10/1/2008

Pornographer Paul F. Little lives and makes his movies in California. But as federal prosecutors decided to build an obscenity case against him, they purchased five of Little’s “Max Hardcore” DVDs via the internet and had them mailed to a post office box in Tampa, ensuring the trial would take place in a U.S. Middle District of Florida courtroom.

Paul Little
Prosecutors purchased porn videos produced by Paul Little (left) and had them mailed to a post office box in Tampa, ensuring the trial would take place in the Middle District of Florida.
Justice Department officials say they tried Little in Tampa because Little’s business, MaxWorld Entertainment, sold the DVDs through an internet server housed in downtown Tampa, just a few blocks from the federal courthouse. But one of Little’s attorneys suspects there’s more to it than that. Jennifer Kinsley, a First Amendment lawyer who helped defend Little, says Tampa fits the Department of Justice’s “overall strategy of prosecuting obscenity in mid- to large-sized markets because a conviction ostensibly sends a loud message to the adult industry as a whole, and not just the individuals on trial, that nowhere is totally safe.”

Orlando First Amendment lawyer Lawrence G. Walters doesn’t buy the government’s explanation, either. “The server location has never meant anything in these cases, and there was no evidence that Mr. Little even knew where the servers were,” Walters says. “It is also possible that since Florida has become such a major location for adult content production in recent years, the feds are trying to scare the industry out of this state.”

More on the Way

Lawrence G. Walters, a free-speech attorney in Orlando, suspects the timing of Paul Little’s trial had something to do with the Bush administration’s final days in office: “Some have suggested that the Obscenity Task Force is trying to initiate as many new cases as possible before a new administration takes over — either as a parting shot at the industry or as the long-promised payoff to the religious right.”

Laura Sweeney, a spokeswoman at the Justice Department’s obscenity section, says nine obscenity cases are still scheduled to go to trial this year or early next, with none in Florida. Sweeney says the U.S. Justice Department has won 55 convictions on obscenity or related charges since 2000, but she was unsure how many of the 55 convictions involved child pornography and how many, like Little’s, involved adult pornography. In the 2007 case of the ACLU v. Alberto Gonzales, it was revealed that there were fewer than 10 obscenity prosecutions between 2005 and 2007.

Meanwhile, federal prosecutors announced they will prosecute another high-profile defendant, alleged New York mob boss John “Junior” Gotti, in the Middle District. While most of the acts alleged in the indictment occurred in New York, prosecutors steered Gotti’s trial — he’s charged with racketeering and drug trafficking — to Tampa after three attempts to prosecute him in New York ended in mistrials. The prosecutors say the Middle District is a legitimate venue because Gotti was expanding his family’s business to Tampa.

If the federal prosecutors are going out of their way to match a trial with a location favorable to their side, the tactic isn’t raising many eyebrows. So-called venue-shopping happens “all the time,” says Sheri D. McWhorter, a labor attorney with Foley & Lardner in Tampa.

Tags: Politics & Law, Central, Tampa Bay, Government/Politics & Law

Digital Access

Add digital to your current subscription, purchase a single digital issue, or start a new subscription to Florida Trend.

An overview of the features and articles in this month's issue of Florida Trend.


Florida Business News

Florida Trend Video Pick

16-Foot Python Caught in the Florida Everglades
16-Foot Python Caught in the Florida Everglades

A near-record 16-foot Burmese python, along with more than 50 eggs, were removed from under a house in the Florida Everglades earlier this month. 

Earlier Videos | Viewpoints@FloridaTrend

Ballot Box

Do you believe funeral homes should be required to post their prices online?

  • Yes
  • No

See Results

Florida Trend Magazine
490 1st Ave S
St Petersburg, FL 33701

© Copyright 2019 Trend Magazines Inc. All rights reserved.