March 22, 2023
The Cologuard test is FDA-approved.
A Cologuard home test detected something suspicious in Nancy Culling's specimen. A colonoscopy revealed a mass.

Cologuard's non-invasive test tests a stool sample for microscopic blood and biomarkers of altered DNA.

Economic Backbone - Cancer Care

Colorectal cancer screening options

An at-home test offers an alternative for some who are skittish about a colonoscopy

Amy Keller | 12/30/2020

While colonoscopies are the most effective screening method for preventing and detecting colon cancer, an estimated 24 million Americans in the recommended age group avoid the test. For nearly 18 years, Nancy Culling was one of them.

The 68-year-old retired teacher, who lives in Fort Myers with her husband, says the invasive nature of the test and the dreaded prep turned her off to the idea. She had neither any symptoms of colon cancer nor a family history of the disease. “Every time the doctor would bring it up, I’d say, ‘That’s not happening,’ ” Culling says. “I felt I was fine.”

In 2019, her doctor suggested she try a non-invasive test called Cologuard, which tests a stool sample for microscopic blood and biomarkers of altered DNA. Culling’s test came back positive. A subsequent colonoscopy revealed a mass. Culling went in for surgery in which a third of her colon was removed. Fortunately, the cancer hadn’t spread, and Culling didn’t need chemotherapy or radiation.

“I was so fortunate,” says Culling, who recently celebrated her one-year anniversary of being cancer-free. “The doctor said that less than 5% of the cells had turned to cancer. That just amazed me that at that level, the Cologuard had detected it.”

Even so, the at-home, FDAapproved test isn’t for everyone. With a target audience of adults 45 and older with an average risk for colorectal cancer, it doesn't replace a colonoscopy for high-risk patients, such as those who’ve had adenomas, inflammatory bowel diseases, a personal or family history of colon cancer or those who have certain hereditary syndromes. False positives and false negatives can also occur. In one study, 13% of individuals had a false positive, suggesting cancer when there was none, and it missed the cancer in 8% of people. Cologuard also is inferior to colonoscopies in that during colonoscopies, gastroenterologists are able to physically see and remove polyps before they become malignant.

While colonoscopy remains the gold standard for colon cancer detection and prevention, Culling points out that for some, the choice isn’t between a colonoscopy and Cologuard — it’s between Cologuard and nothing. “For me, I wouldn’t do the colonoscopy,” she says. “Now I say to everybody, talk to your doctor. If you are against the colonoscopy, do something like this. I am a firm believer that the best screening you can do is the one you will do.”


Read more in Florida Trend's January issue.
Select from the following options:

Tags: Healthcare, Life Sciences, Technology/Innovation, Cancer Care, Economic Backbone, Feature

Florida Business News

Florida News Releases

Florida Trend Video Pick

The story behind Parkesdale Market’s famous Plant City strawberry shortcakes
The story behind Parkesdale Market’s famous Plant City strawberry shortcakes

Thousands make the pilgrimage to Plant City during strawberry season to eat strawberry shortcakes piled high. From January to the end of March (and if the weather cooperates, April) they line up to taste at Parkesdale Farm Market — part garden center, part produce market and part ice cream shop.


Video Picks | Viewpoints@FloridaTrend

Ballot Box

Do you think banning electric vehicle (EV) use during a hurricane evacuation is a good idea?

  • Yes
  • No
  • Unsure/Need more information
  • Other (Please share your comments in the comment section below)

See Results

Florida Trend Media Company
490 1st Ave S
St Petersburg, FL 33701

© Copyright 2023 Trend Magazines Inc. All rights reserved.