Subscribe to Florida Trend


September 22, 2018


Dumping Grounds

Clay County leaders are trying to get to the bottom of the county's latest scandal.

Bob Snell | 6/1/2005
In a county that has seen its share of scandal, the discovery of illegal dumping on a massive scale at numerous Clay County "borrow" pits has sent shock waves through the community.

Longtime County Manager Bob Wilson and Department of Public Works Director Arthur Ivey resigned hours before the County Commission was to decide their fates. As the county continues to discover new illegal dumpsites, officials say they have no idea how the already cash-strapped county will come up with the tens (perhaps hundreds) of millions of dollars it will take to clean up the acres of contaminated land.

One dump contained the remains of a junked fire engine.

Agents from the FBI, State Attorney's Office and Department of Environmental Protection continue to sift through debris at the three largest pits discovered to date -- landfills that were supposed to store only clay, lime rock, dirt and other materials used mainly for road projects. Instead, the decades-old dumps were crammed with tons of construction debris -- some of it tainted with lead, arsenic and other hazardous materials.

"This is probably the largest scandal to ever hit this county," Commission Chairman George Bush said at a recent board meeting.

Initial tests show no contaminants have seeped into several nearby drinking water wells. Still, the county has promised to furnish bottled water to nearby homes until a full environmental accounting is completed.

Problems at Clay County landfills first came to light in June 2003 when commission auditor Michael Price found the Public Works Department had not charged a contractor who had dumped approximately 150,000 cubic yards of material at one pit. Following the report, rumors began to fly about questionable practices at several other landfills.

Last September, the FBI and State Attorney's Office put two investigators on the case. The agents hounded Public Works employees (conducting stakeouts at some homes) and installed hidden cameras at several pits. In March, they raided at least one landfill as employees scurried to bury a load of construction debris.

With the main dumpsites identified and Wilson and Ivey out of office, the investigation has become more methodical. Investigators are reportedly interested in learning which building contractors were involved and what they may have paid county employees. They also want to learn who in county government knew of the decades-long practice.

The dumping scandal is but the latest in a string of blunders to have, in the words of Bush, "given the county a huge black eye." Longtime Sheriff Scott Lancaster failed to win re-election last November after it was revealed that he used a county credit card for lavish personal expenses. Several years ago, Clerk of Court John Keene was forced to resign after his office "lost" $16 million in what he called an "accounting error."

Tags: Politics & Law, Northeast, Government/Politics & Law

Digital Access

Add digital to your current subscription, purchase a single digital issue, or start a new subscription to Florida Trend.

An overview of the features and articles in this month's issue of Florida Trend.


Florida Business News

Florida Trend Video Pick

Miami Beach considers annexing western Venetian Islands
Miami Beach considers annexing western Venetian Islands

Two of the Venetian Islands are part of Miami while the other four belong to Miami Beach. Some residents of Biscayne and San Marco islands say they want to join Miami Beach, but they face an uphill battle.

Earlier Videos | Viewpoints@FloridaTrend

Ballot Box

With Florida's government projecting a positive budget outlook, what do you think is the most important for state to invest in?

  • Education
  • Environment
  • Health care reform
  • Infrastructure
  • Not spending it, keeping cash reserve
  • Public safety
  • Other (comments welcome)

See Results

Ballot Box