July 23, 2016

Ave Maria

Leap of Faith

Dominoes founder Tom Monaghan expected things to go smoothly when he began moving his Roman Catholic college from Michigan to Southwest Florida. But ...

Amy Keller | 9/1/2007

Condos, not condoms

Meanwhile, controversy over Ave Maria spread outside of the Wolverine state. At the Boston Catholic Men’s Conference in 2005, Monaghan said in a speech that he would “control all the commercial real estate, so there’s not going to be any pornography sold in this town. We’re controlling the cable system. The pharmacies are not going to be able to sell condoms or dispense contraceptives.”

» "I was brought up to believe we’re born for a purpose. We’re supposed to live a certain way, and if we do, we’ll be rewarded and if we don’t, we’ll be punished. And I believe that. I think that’s the way I ought to live. I don’t always do it, of course." — Tom Monaghan

National media picked up on the story, and the American Civil Liberties Union lashed out: “This is not Catholicism — this is not a story about Catholicism. It’s a story about any religious group trying to exercise governmental power,” Howard Simon, executive director of Florida’s ACLU, told MSNBC talk show host Tucker Carlson in 2006.

Monaghan eventually toned down his rhetoric. A month after the ACLU’s backlash, he and Barron Collier CEO Paul Marinelli issued a joint statement to address the “growing misperception” that Ave Maria would be a Catholic-only enclave. “Because the university’s leadership, in accordance with Catholic teachings, opposes the sale of contraceptives, retailers in the town have been asked to refrain from selling contraceptives. However, it is critical to note that no restrictions will be enforced on contraceptives or any other inventory.”

Spreading the Word: Good Morning America’ reporter Gigi Stone interviews an Ave Maria nun during a “town fest” in July. [Photo: Dawn DiNardo]
In a recent interview with Florida Trend, Monaghan emphasized the town’s more secular virtues. Ave Maria will be “family oriented” and “wholesome,” Monaghan says. He says the university will operate a top-notch parochial K-12 school for families in the area.

Monaghan’s business partners navigate carefully around Monaghan’s ideology. During a tour of the new town in July, Blake Gable, town project manager and vice president of real estate for Barron Collier, mentions several times that he’s an Episcopalian. Meanwhile, Pulte Homes, which is building the residential portion of Ave Maria Town, has adopted the marketing slogan “Every Family. Every Lifestyle. Every Dream.” In fact, federal fair housing laws prohibit discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status and national origin.

The home builder declined to give any information about the demographics of Ave Maria home buyers. “Nobody can answer that question,” responded Beth Cocchiarella, Florida area director of public relations for Pulte Homes.

Gable insists that Monaghan makes for a good business partner. “He’s doing what’s in his heart — how can you possibly fault him? He sets high standards and high goals, and I hope he’d say we’re good partners. They’re incredibly fair and honest people. We haven’t had a lot of issues.”

Tags: North Central, Education

Digital Access

Add digital to your current subscription, purchase a single digital issue, or start a new subscription to Florida Trend.

An overview of the features and articles in this month's issue of Florida Trend.


Florida Business News

Florida Trend Video Pick

Taking the kids to Kennedy Space Center
Taking the kids to Kennedy Space Center

Space fans old and young will enjoy the many sides of KSC: The sheer size of the suspended Saturn 5 rocket, the IMax movies, the bus tour, the new Angry Birds exhibit, the rocket garden, climbing through the miniature International Space Center, trying out a re-creation of a shuttle landing -- and much more.

Earlier Videos | Viewpoints@FloridaTrend

Ballot Box

In his acceptance speech at the RNC, Donald Trump painted a dark picture, portraying the United States as a diminished and even humiliated nation. He said these are times of crisis, and our way of life is threatened. Do you agree with Trump?

  • Yes - completely agree
  • On the fence
  • Don't agree, see things more optimistically

See Results

Ballot Box