Subscribe to Florida Trend


May 23, 2018

Party Politics

Can Democrats Pounce?

Public frustration is an opportunity for Florida's minority party, but can Rep. Dan Gelber offer a compelling better way?

Neil Skene | 1/1/2008

One is political. Rubio may be bipartisan in manner, but he has picked up the mantle of Bush conservatism — starve government, help business, tout “values” — and is Crist’s chief adversary right now. This could mean Gelber’s influence on legislation will be for naught if the bills can’t get past Crist and the Senate. In the October special session to pass a Jan. 29 ballot initiative on property taxes, Gelber helped craft the House position (clearly more favorable to commercial interests). But a simpler, homeowner-oriented initiative from the Senate prevailed after Crist urged the House to accept it.

Gelber’s other problem is his own: Already halfway through his two-year term as leader, he has to produce coherent and compelling alternatives that can steal a march on the other guys. He has to draw cameras to news conferences, money to candidates and voters to polls. So far, instead of refocusing attention on big issues he says the Legislature is ignoring, he has succumbed to the political allure of one-time cuts in property insurance and property taxes.

It’s hard to talk seriously about education and healthcare without talking about money. And when it comes to talking money, Democrats remain chastened by fear of the “tax and spend” label, even as Republicans are now chastened by Democratic gains in 2006.

An illustration of this Democratic straddle is Gelber’s current focus in education: Replacing or supplementing the FCAT with a test that recognizes superior performance in a broad range of subjects, perhaps with an honors diploma similar to the Regents Diploma in New York. “We need to get a good
accountability system,” says Gelber, “and then argue about how much money we need to put into the system.”

Maybe a “Regents exam” for Florida is a good idea. But it is not even
remotely as ambitious or comprehensive as, say, then-Gov. Bob Graham’s goal in the 1980s of getting Florida quickly into the top one-fourth of states in multiple measures of school quality. Graham focused heavily on “inputs,” not results, but you can’t just test and not invest, either.

Bigger megaphone

It is not Gelber’s job alone to create a winning platform and political strategy, but he’s the Democrats’ best hope at the moment. His Senate counterpart, Steve Geller of Hallandale, is leaving the Legislature after this year. Their successors, Sen. Al Lawson of Tallahassee and second-term Rep. Franklin Sands of Weston, have little record of policy creativity.

Strategic positioning is difficult for any minority leader in a legislative setting. The other party controls the legislative agenda, campaigns in districts gerrymandered to protect them and now even commandeers Democratic social rhetoric [“Trojan Donkey?” April 2007].

“Our job really is to be the honest opposition to challenge the majority party on its excesses and overreaching,” says Gelber, “and to show there’s a better way.”
That “better way” is the hard part.

One option, if Gelber wants Democrats to match or beat their gain in House seats the last time around, is to get himself a clearer vision and a bigger megaphone (including an “investment” in advertising to promote the message).
But here’s another option: Gelber and Rubio, who has spoken of a desire for “world-class education,” could put aside the “issues of the election cycle” and spend however many days it takes in an “emergency” conference on education policy — just the two of them, though consulting as needed with their education lieutenants. The goal: To agree on as much as possible to achieve a real leap forward in educational achievement by the 2012 election cycle. If details stump them, they can leave that part of the policy-making to the State Board of Education and local school boards.

They could even dare the Senate to reject it without coming up with something equally comprehensive and better.

Something like that would make it truly Gelber’s moment. Rubio’s too.

Tags: Politics & Law, North Central, Government/Politics & Law

Digital Access

Add digital to your current subscription, purchase a single digital issue, or start a new subscription to Florida Trend.

An overview of the features and articles in this month's issue of Florida Trend.


Florida Business News

Florida Trend Video Pick

Why are Miami wages so low? 'No. 1 startup city' comes with a downside
Why are Miami wages so low? 'No. 1 startup city' comes with a downside

Tiffany Zadi sells leather fashions for her one-person business called Heist. As part of that she does a lot of shows and pop-up stores and events around Miami as well as out of town.

Earlier Videos | Viewpoints@FloridaTrend

Ballot Box

Do you think Florida's election systems are secure?

  • No
  • I have doubts
  • Yes

See Results

Ballot Box