March 1, 2015

The Texas-Florida Connection

Hold Your Horses, Gov. Rick Scott

Can Florida emulate Texas in creating jobs? Here's a comparison.

Cynthia Barnett | 9/28/2011

Growth and Development Regulations

Houston Metro
Houston is the largest metro area in the nation with no zoning.

Texas' metro areas share "an unparalleled openness to growth and development," according to a Brookings Institution analysis of growth regulation in all 50 states. Planning is weak. Texas counties are not allowed to adopt zoning — or even binding comprehensive plans. The largest cities can zone unincorporated land up to five miles out. Houston is notorious for being the largest metro area in the nation with no zoning at all. Among the cities with zoning, "it is relatively easy to find someone in city government to help a project," says Hillwood's Michael K. Berry. Land-development review and securing roads and infrastructure also tend to be speedy, he says.

Scott has already tried to mimic the Texas approach by reorganizing the state's Department of Community Affairs, the agency many viewed as the chief custodian of the state's strong growth management laws. Scott saw the old DCA as a roadblock to business growth. "It's not that you don't get the permit," he says. "It's that it takes forever, and you don't know the whole process. If you're going to put your dollars at risk, you're going to eliminate as many variables as you can. If something costs you a lot to get there, you're going to say 'I'll go someplace else.'"

It remains to be seen whether Florida's already congested metro areas will choose to become even more like their Texas counterparts. Well-established costs of sprawl are much in evidence in the Lone Star State — most obviously, a lack of green space and traffic. The nation's Urban Mobility Report cites Houston and Dallas-Fort Worth as two of the top 10 worst congested metros in the U.S. Florida's most congested city, Miami, is No. 11.

Go to Links What do you think about the whole Florida -vs- Texas debate? Let us know, click to comment at the end of this article.

Tags: Politics & Law, Around Florida, Government/Politics & Law

Digital Access

Add digital to your current subscription, purchase a single ditgital issue, or start a new subscription to Florida Trend.

An overview of the features and articles in this month's issue of Florida Trend.


Florida Business News

Florida Trend Video Pick

Brevard man finalist for one-way trip to Mars
Brevard man finalist for one-way trip to Mars

A Merritt Island man has advanced to the final round of 100 candidates vying to be selected as astronauts by the Mars One Foundation, which wants to establish a human settlement on the Red Planet in the next decade.

Earlier Videos | Viewpoints@FloridaTrend

Ballot Box

Gov Scott has proposed to increase funding to education, and half of those monies will come from property taxes. The debate is: A) is Scott's proposal a tax? Or, B) is Scott just using new monies that would come in because property values are increasing?

  • A) It's a tax
  • B) It's not a tax - only tapping natural increases in revenue

See Results

Ballot Box