September 15, 2014

Medical Malpractice

Fear Factor: Medical Malpractice

Legal reforms have brightened the medical malpractice horizon, but physicians are still wary of lawsuits -- and still angry at high insurance premiums. More than 2,000 now choose to go without insurance.

Amy Keller | 3/1/2007

After years of warfare, the smoke is clearing on Florida's medical-malpractice front.


Illustration: James Yang

Some changes -- a $500,000 cap on pain and suffering damages passed by the Legislature in 2003, for example, and a constitutional limit on lawyers' fees in malpractice cases that voters approved in 2004 -- appear to be taking hold, with a recent decline in the number of med-mal claims, according to state insurance news regulators.

Other evidence: In 2005, the 15 medical-malpractice insurance companies in Florida that provide coverage for 80% of the market had to pay out 40.2% of premiums to cover losses -- a favorable percentage compared with other populous states such as New York, Illinois and Pennsylvania.

Those 15 companies also made more than $800 million in profits. The market is now attractive enough that between October 2005 and October 2006, eight new companies, most of them risk-retention groups structured like mutual insurers, started selling med-mal insurance in the state.

In the wake of the reforms, some physicians already are paying less for their med-mal insurance. And last December, Jacksonville-based First Professional Insurance Co. (FPIC), the state's largest writer of medical-malpractice insurance policies, filed for a rate decrease that will reduce premiums an average of 8%.

The course of the med-mal wars also has put the lie to some of the more egregious claims about the impact of lawsuits. A 2003 General Accounting Office report found that oft-cited claims of physician departures in Florida were "anecdotal, not extensive" and sometimes "inaccurate." Despite claims by provider groups that malpractice pressures were making it hard to retain and recruit physicians, the GAO found that the number of new medical licenses in Florida had actually increased and the number of physicians per capita was unchanged.

For all the good news in the wake of the reforms, however, the med-mal atmosphere remains cloudy and complex. Few physicians are celebrating.

Tags: Politics & Law, North Central, Government/Politics & Law, Healthcare

Digital Access

DIRECT DIGITAL ACCESS
Add digital to your current subscription, purchase a single ditgital issue, or start a new subscription to Florida Trend.

TABLE OF CONTENTS
An overview of the features and articles in this month's issue of Florida Trend.

ACCESS THIS ISSUE »

Florida Business News

Florida Trend Video Pick

Mai-Kai's in the running for best restroom in the country
Mai-Kai's in the running for best restroom in the country

Mai-Kai believes its thrones deserve a crown. The iconic Polynesian restaurant in Fort Lauderdale is among 10 finalists in a contest for best washroom in the country. (Click here if video is not playing.)

Earlier Videos | Viewpoints@FloridaTrend

Ballot Box

Will U.S. air strikes in Iraq and Syria solve the ISIS problem?

  • Air strikes might not be enough, but we shouldn't get more involved
  • No, limited involvement will not work, long-term engagement is essential to stabilizing the region
  • Yes, I think air strikes will solve the problem

See Results

Ballot Box
Subscribe